Vidya Bhushan Rawat
Human Rights Defender
In fact, one of the biggest tragedies of South Asia or Indian subcontinent is that the whole partition debate revolved around Hindus and Muslims who might have fought with each other many time, had conflicting views on many things but had so many commonalities of working together, living together and practising similar cultural values. When so many good things were there, I can say we had equal number of bad things. While I celebrate the cultural mosaic of Hindus-Muslims-Buddhists-Sikhs-Christians and all others who are contributed to our common cultural heritage, we must not hesitate to speak up against all those evils which too have become our ‘common’ heritage. Caste and untouchability today has transcended our nations, religions and ethnicities and it is time we must speak up against this evil. We need to seriously introspect. It can’t be allowed to browbeat the other because except for India, people were not much aware of the caste system in South Asia. Except for Hinduism, most of the people were not aware that caste had penetrated in South Asian Islam, Christianity and Sikkhism and people remained isolated, ostracized and faced untouchability despite so-called conversion.
Caste is a disease that has inflicted everyone across the region. It was varna system but today the virus has gone into those who technically have no caste in their foundations. Thus, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs too have castes in South Asia and apart from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri-Lanka and Nepal suffer from this grave disease. So, when we talk about mission annihilation of castes, we have to take up the realities of modern times and work accordingly. We should not forget that Dr. Ambedkar was a modern man and therefore he challenged the supremacy of scriptures and felt that if the scriptures are not per as our modern world, rule of law and do not preach equality of human being including gender then, they should amended. Why modern democratic laws are better than the religious scriptures because in the modern laws you have the power to amend it and that is why your constitution can be amended as per the needs of the people accordingly but you can’t think of even speaking about the religious laws who we feel are universal.
Lahore is historical because Baba Saheb Ambedkar was invited here by the Jat Pat Todak Mandal in 1936 by its secretary Sant Ram to speak on annihilation of castes. Mandal was an Arya Samaji and a reformist one and they had expected that Dr. Ambedkar would just speak about the menace of untouchability and how to fight against it. So, he was asked to preside over the programme meant to speak on the annihilation of caste. The organisers asked him to send his speech in advance so that it could be distributed. As you might know that he sent the speech but it shocked the organizers which shocked them as they were not expecting that Dr. Ambedkar would challenge the basic tenants or foundation of varna system. Sant Ram requested him to change his presidential address which Dr. Ambedkar refused saying that you cannot censor the speech of a person presiding over a programme, as how to speak. A man of great courage and conviction, Dr. Ambedkar later published that speech which is known as ‘Annihilation of Castes’ in May 1936. Every student of social sciences and political science must study that book but please do not look into these argument with one particular religion because as I said caste may be considered to be the root of varna system but it has inflicted everywhere so our challenge is much bigger. Caste divisions will ultimately kill society; they divide and are inhuman to say the least. Perpetual practices of caste system are anti-democratic and remain the biggest threat to our democracy as without life being democratic we cannot strengthen political democracy. Baba Saheb Ambedkar had warned about long back in 1950 that two individuals have to be equal in social life for the political democracy to succeed.
“Perpetual practices of caste system are anti-democratic and remain the biggest threat to our democracy as without life being democratic we cannot strengthen political democracy. Baba Saheb Ambedkar had warned about long back in 1950 that two individuals have to be equal in social life for the political democracy to succeed.”
Eighty Two years have passed since then. Dr.Ambedkar speech became historic. People were reading it according to their conveniences. Many were trying to hide it so that it does not expose but the one thing it has done that it raised the consciousness among the Dalit Bahujans and not merely among those who were part of the Hinduism but today the issue of Dalit and assertion has risen beyond Hinduism. The Pasmandas are seeking their right and representations, so are Christians. Ambedkar’s legacy has become stronger and powerful in India as it believed in democracy and modernism. Today, Dr. Baba Saheb Ambedkar remains the most powerful icon of freedom and freedom not just from the yokes of the imperial power but the caste forces. Thank to Dr. Ambedkar’s valiant efforts to provide justice to the marginalized sections, their representation in India’s political structure, in Parliament, in Assemblies is high. Today, the assertive Ambedkarite raise their voice and speak up, and represent them.
Hence, when I am speaking here in Lahore, I would like to share a few thoughts about how can the conditions of Dalits be bettered in Pakistan. I am sure you won’t deny the fact that there are a large number of Dalits in Pakistan, who live in Sind and Punjab provinces and whose social and economic conditions are not great. If in India they have political representation, job reservation, and now they are excelling in business and other sectors too but Dalits elsewhere in South Asia do not have constitutional provisions to protect them. Nepal is doing better in this direction as their constituent assembly has proportionate representation for them as well as they have also formed National Dalit Commission. Both Bangladesh and Pakistan have done very little to improve their condition.
The conditions of Churas or Valmikis or what you call Christians or Maseehs in Pakistan is a matter of grave concern. They have faced numerous charges in the name of blasphemy. It is time for Pakistan government to protect the rights of the Dalits. While word Bhangi is banned in India, in Pakistan it is used freely. There are no spaces for the Dalits in jobs and other important institutions. A senior journalist who happened to be a Dalit narrated how in his newsrooms the upper caste Muslims would not drink water with him. The Pasmanda movement in India speaks of discrimination with them by the high caste Muslims. We have Halalkhors who are engaged in manual scavenging, Kalandars, Julahas, Naisetc who engaged in menial work and are looked down upon. Even in a place like Kashmir, one particular community of Wattals are engaged in the work of manual scavenging hence all the talk of all are equal fall flat and may be theory only and not in practice.
According to Dawn on June 2nd, 2017, Sewage worker Irfan Maseeh died of non-treatment by the doctor because he did not want to touch him and compelled that his body be washed. It is shocking. I felt only the caste Hindus do it but the caste Muslims are no different than the caste Hindus. That is why I have said it so many times; the caste culture has corrupted our social system everywhere. Somewhere caste system actually strengthens feudal values and South Asia remains a power center for both. When the system is suitable to us, we don’t want any change. We would do a bit of ‘reform’ because of people’s pressure but would not accept full changes which would alter the power equations. Unless these equations are changed, I won’t say, we have attained freedom. This was the incident in Umarkot and frankly speaking shocked us but did not surprise. Religious answers to issue of untouchability has failed because religions in South Asia have rarely democratized themselves in terms of caste and gender and the agrarian structure of our society without any reforms continue to strengthen the status quo.
Dr. Ambedkar had said, “If there is any cause of freedom in this Indian turmoil for independence, it is the cause of the Untouchables. The cause of Hindus and the cause of Mussalman is not the cause of freedom. There is a struggle for power as distinguished from freedom. Consequently it has always been a matter of surprise to me that no party and no organization devoted to the cause of freedom has so far interested itself in the Untouchables
Even in the Parliament, I don’t think there is fair representation for the Dalits in Pakistan. The Dalit Sujag Tehreek in Sind is doing a wonderful work to bring Dalits to one table and suggest that the population of Dalits in Sind is very high but most of them are absolutely landless and unrepresented politically. Feudalism is rampant and made them prone to violence. It is important for the lawmakers in Pakistan to give the Dalits their fair share in power. The seats which are reserved for the minorities must also be extended to Dalits and they be given representation everywhere including media.
It is time South Asia show its concern to eradicate hunger and poverty which is its biggest challenge. We know that our societies take deep pride in their lineages’. We still have honored killings among all our communities and forced bonded labour is still prevalent and the reason for that is our feudal system and supremacy of our caste identities. How will the rural power equation changed unless there are radical land reforms and the benefit not gone to the rural poor predominantly Dalits and other marginalized. The violence against Dalits in all the South Asian countries has its root in caste biases and failure of the rule of law.
We live in a society of contradiction and Dr. Baba Saheb Ambedkar mentioned it well. Our constitutional forefathers as well as yours too, Dr.Ambedkar, JawaharLal Nehru and Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah were foresighted, modern and progressive. When Nehru was talking about tryst with Destiny and Baba Saheb Ambedkar reminded us of contradictions of life, Jinnah spoke of a modern progressive Pakistan.
Speaking in the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, on August 11th 1947, Mohammad Ali Jinnah said: ‘You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place of worship in this State of Pakistan…You may belong to any religion or caste or creed—that has nothing to do with the business of the State…We are starting in the days when there is no discrimination between one caste or creed and another. We are starting with this fundamental principle that we are all citizens and equal citizens of one state. We are starting with this fundamental principle that we are all citizens and equal citizens of one state. Now I think we should keep that in front of us as our ideal and you will find that in course of time Hindus would cease to be Hindus and Muslims would cease to be Muslims, not in the religious sense, because that is the personal faith of each individual, but in the principles of justice and fair play without any, as is put in the political language, prejudice or ill-will, in other words, partially or favoritism. My guiding principle will be justice and complete impartially, and I am sure that with your support and co-operation, I can look forward to Pakistan becoming one of the greatest Nations of the World. All the same in this division it was impossible to avoid the question of minorities being in one Dominion or the other. Now that was unavoidable. There is no other solution. Now what shall we do? Now, if we want to make this great State of Pakistan happy and prosperous we should wholly and solely concentrate on the well-being of the masses and the poor. If you will work in co-operation, forgetting the past, burying the hatchet you are bound to succeed.’
We need to ask ourselves as how much have these dreams of Quaid been achieved? Tragically, within three years, the important member of the constituent assembly and the first law minister of Pakistan Jogendra Nath Mandal, who was one of the very close associate of Dr. Baba Saheb Ambedkar, had to return to India. Frustrated at the maltreatment given to minorities particularly those living in East Bengal, his dream collapsed and he resigned from the cabinet of Mr. Liaquat Ali Khan on October 8th, 1950. It reflect the pain and anguish of the man who dedicated his life for the cause of your country but felt betrayed at the end as discrimination against Hindus and scheduled castes remain rampant. Mandal’s resignation remains an important document of history for all who wanted to know what ails the polity in Pakistan. It gives us lot of ideas to introspect.
“We would do a bit of ‘reform’ because of people’s pressure but would not accept full changes which would alter the power equations. Unless these equations are changed, I won’t say, we have attained freedom.”
….to be continued in next issue