• HOME
  • UNMAI
  • VIDUTHALAI
  • PERIYAR TV
  • PERIYAR PINJU
Newsletter
Modern rationalist
Advertisement
  • Periyar Speaks
  • Social Justice
  • Rationalist
  • Feminism
  • Lovable Life
No Result
View All Result
  • Periyar Speaks
  • Social Justice
  • Rationalist
  • Feminism
  • Lovable Life
No Result
View All Result
Modern rationalist
No Result
View All Result

‘Signs of Pseudoscience’

by Modern Rationalist
August 18, 2021
in Universe
0
‘Signs of Pseudoscience’

IGNOU’s new astrology course points to a split personality, rings a warning bell

v10

Related articles

DECEPTIVE FAITH

March 19, 2025
WHY IS THIS QUOTATION FROM WINSTON CHURCHILL NOT WELL KNOWN?

WHY IS THIS QUOTATION FROM WINSTON CHURCHILL NOT WELL KNOWN?

December 21, 2024

Prof. Rajesh Kochhar
Formerly Director of National Institute of Science, Technology and Development Studies (CSIR)

The Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) has just introduced a two-year MA in astrology. All along we have been telling high school students that the earth is just a planet, while the sun is a star, millions of kilometres distant. Now at the MA level, we will be teaching them that the sun goes around the earth and is at par with the moon.

Of the 1,000-odd universities in India, about 20 offer courses in astrology. The Banaras Hindu University has several departments related to Sanskrit where astrology courses are conducted. But, then it came up at a different time and in a different milieu. In the post-Independence era, IGNOU is the first well-regarded mainstream university to patronise astrology.

Astrology needs to be discussed at two levels: In the context of modern astronomy, and within its own framework. Astrology is a creation of the time when the human perception of the universe was based on the principle that seeing is believing. The universe was assumed to be centred on the earth and human beings. There was no concept of the depth of the sky; it was seen as a tapestry and the star patterns on it were taken to be physically significant. Most importantly, it was assumed that the movements in the sky carried divine signals. If what we know of the cosmos today had been known 2,000 years ago, astrology as we know it would not have come into being. The popularity of astrology does not legitimise it nor does its antiquity sanctify it.

Of late, India has developed a split personality. On the one hand, we are proud of our IITs and world-class space and missile programmes. We want our universities to figure prominently in world lists, and we want our scientists to win the Nobel Prize. At the same time, we are developing an unhealthy obsession with ancient India. In 1862, Bapu Deva Sastri, the most outstanding astronomy scholar of his time, publicly declared that ancient Indian astronomy should be upgraded in the light of modern developments. We can be justly proud of our ancient scientific accomplishments. They, however, should not be seen as “our” science versus “their” science, but as intermediary stages in the development of world science. Many famous mathematical equations were first formulated and solved by Indian astronomers in the context of the calculation of planetary orbits.

It is important to use terms in their correct sense. There is a tendency to use the phrase Vedic astronomy very loosely, as an umbrella term for astronomy in pre-Islamic times. It should be distinguished from its successor Siddhantic astronomy which came into effect in the 6th century CE. Vedic astronomy talks of 27 or 28 stars/star groups known as nakshatras and uses them to mark the position of geocentric planets and comets, etc. Zodiac signs, weekdays and the present-day Vikrami calendar, which are integral parts of Siddhantic astronomy, and the astrological system based on it, do not figure in Vedic astronomy.

There is a semi-articulated sense of inadequacy while discussing astrology. Jiwaji University, Gwalior, declares that jyotirvigyan “will add a new dimension for research in the fields of Hindu mathematics, Vastushastra, meteorological studies, agriculture science, space science, etc.” This is a dishonest attempt to lead impressionable minds into believing that the science of 1,500 years ago can be relevant for modern disciplines like space science.

IGNOU promises that its astrology course will create employment opportunities. This is probably true, but is it desirable? Recognised educational institutions, especially those owned by the government, should equip their students for productive and enlightened roles in the world of today and tomorrow. Our education system should not propagate bogus and discredited ideas and train the students to cash in on other people’s insecurities.

If the state wants to see India make a name for itself in global science and technology, it must not be seen as supporting pseudo-science.

Courtesy: ‘The Indian Express’

Tags: ancient Indian astronomyAstrologyBapu Deva SastriIndira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU)Nobel Prizepost-Independence eraProf. Rajesh KochharPseudoscienceSanskritSiddhantic astronomysplit personalityUniverseVastushastra
Previous Post

Dignified Well-being in Public Healthcare

Next Post

Making Fr Stan the last casualty of the UAPA

Related Posts

DECEPTIVE FAITH

by Modern Rationalist
March 19, 2025
0

I would not have bothered so much to oppose religious extremism and to deny the existence of God, if this...

WHY IS THIS QUOTATION FROM WINSTON CHURCHILL NOT WELL KNOWN?

WHY IS THIS QUOTATION FROM WINSTON CHURCHILL NOT WELL KNOWN?

by Modern Rationalist
December 21, 2024
0

He had highlighted India’s “brahmin problem” very well way back in a speech on March 18, 1931 in Albert Hall,...

A. Padmanaban ‘Ananda Illam’, New 4, IX Cross Street, Sastri Nagar, Chennai-20. Phone: 4910865

by Modern Rationalist
December 21, 2024
0

அன்புள்ள அருமை சகோதரர் தலைவர் திரு.வீரமணி அவர்களுக்கு, வணக்கம். தங்களுடைய பிறந்தநாள் மிகவும் முக்கிய நாளாகும். தங்களுக்கு எல்லா நலன்களும், கீர்த்தியும் சேரவேண்டுமென்று வாழ்த்துகிறேன். தங்கள் சேவை,...

PERIYAR RAMASAMY’S UTTAR PRADESH CONNECTION

PERIYAR RAMASAMY’S UTTAR PRADESH CONNECTION

by Modern Rationalist
December 21, 2024
0

According to available details, Periyar EV Ramasamy came to Uttar Pradesh in 1944, 1959 and 1968. In 1944 and 1959,...

DELIBERATE CONCEALMENT

by Modern Rationalist
December 21, 2024
0

It is customary for the Union government’s Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) to publish the data on reservation in...

Load More

All Issues

Select Month
    • HOME
    • UNMAI
    • VIDUTHALAI
    • PERIYAR TV
    • PERIYAR PINJU
    Call us: +91 89390 89888

    © 2023 Modern Rationalist Magazine

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Periyar Speaks
    • Social Justice
    • Rationalist
    • Feminism
    • Lovable Life

    © 2023 Modern Rationalist Magazine